Skip to content
Floskool

Chapter 1 · The resource

Unfair or fake reviews, and how to report them

Free lesson 12 minGroup Flopix

Follow this course in your space: your progress is saved, and the community answers your questions.

Follow for free

Some reviews aren't just negative: they're fake, unfair or off topic. Someone who never came in, a review meant for another business, insults, a wave of 1-star ratings overnight. These situations are infuriating, and that's exactly when you need to be the most methodical.

Two things happen in parallel: reply calmly, for the readers, and report, to ask Google to look at the review.

Identify the type of review

SituationCluesWhat to do
Harsh but real reviewThe customer did come in, their feelings are exaggeratedReply as you would to a negative review (previous lesson). Don't report it.
Unknown personNo trace of a visit, an order or an appointmentCalm reply + report
Wrong businessThe review talks about a service you don't offer, another addressCalm reply + report
Insults, hateful or discriminatory languageThe content itself is offensiveReport, very short reply or none
Conflict of interestFormer employee, identified competitor, someone close to a personal disputeReport, neutral reply
Wave of reviewsSeveral negative reviews in a short time, often with no text or the same toneReport each review, then contact Google support

Careful: a review that feels unfair to you doesn't necessarily break the rules. A customer has the right not to like your work and to say so, even clumsily. Google removes reviews that break its rules, not reviews you don't like.

Reply without losing your temper

Your readers don't know who's right. They watch who stays calm. Your reply should be factual, short, with no accusation.

The person who never came in

Hello, we can't find any record of your [visit / order / appointment] and we're unable to identify the situation you describe. If you did come to see us, please call us at [phone]: we want to understand what happened. [Your first name]

Note: you don't write "you never came in" or "fake review." You state the facts, and you leave the door open. If the person is sincere, they'll call. If not, readers will understand.

The wrong business

Hello, it looks like this review is about another business: we don't offer [the service mentioned] and we're located [your address or your neighborhood]. If we're mistaken, please contact us at [phone]. [Your first name]

The aggressive or insulting review

Hello, we regret the tone of this message. We're still available to talk calmly at [phone] if you'd like. [Your first name]

Or no reply at all, if the review is nothing but insults: a reply can fuel the exchange. Either way, report it.

The suspected conflict of interest

Hello, we don't recognize our customers' experience in this message. We can be reached at [phone] for any questions. [Your first name]

Never name the person you suspect, and don't discuss a dispute in public.

How to report a review

The exact labels change from time to time. Here's how it works:

  1. From your profile, signed in to the account that manages it, open the list of reviews.
  2. On the review in question, open the menu (the three dots) and choose the option to report the review.
  3. Choose the reason that fits best: fake content or spam, off topic, conflict of interest, offensive content, harassment, personal information...
  4. Write down the date of the report in a document, with a screenshot of the review.

In its Business Profile help, Google also offers a review management tool that lets you follow the status of a report and, if the review wasn't removed, ask for a second look. Check Google's help on reviews for the current process.

What to know before you report

  • The review takes time, and the decision belongs to Google.
  • Reporting all your negative reviews in bulk doesn't help and can hurt your credibility. Only report the ones that clearly break the rules.
  • Never ask people close to you to report a review or to write positive reviews to "make up for it": then you would be the one breaking the rules.
  • Don't reply differently because you reported it: the calm reply stays online as long as the review exists.

When to go further

If a review contains serious, false accusations (theft, putting people in danger, comments about your private life), or if you're facing an organized campaign, keep all the evidence (dated screenshots, links) and get advice from a legal professional. The time limits to take action can be short. Never threaten the author publicly in your reply.

Example: Thomas, auto mechanic

One Monday morning, Thomas finds three 1-star reviews posted over the weekend, while the shop was closed. None of them matches a customer. He replies to each one with the "unknown person" template, reports all three for fake content, writes down the dates and takes screenshots. He keeps asking his real customers for reviews, as usual. He then follows the status of his reports with the review management tool.

Your turn

  1. Reread your negative reviews and sort them with the table at the top: real, unknown, wrong business, insulting, conflict of interest.
  2. For each real review, apply the previous lesson. For the others, write a calm reply using the templates above.
  3. Create a "Reports" document with the date, the screenshot and the reason for each report.