Chapter 2 · Year-end and new methods
Giving feedback to a coworker
Follow this course in your space: your progress is saved, and the community answers your questions.
Follow for free"You could be a little more careful." Your coworker has no idea what to be careful about, feels judged, and will probably do the same thing again. On the flip side, a lot of feedback never gets given: you let it slide, fix it yourself, then blow up at the fifth slip.
Useful feedback has three parts, happens quickly and in private. And it works just as well for saying what's going right.
The method: facts, impact, request
- The facts: what happened, something a camera could have recorded. A date, a document, an action. Not "you're always late," but "the Martin quote went out Thursday instead of Tuesday."
- The impact: what it caused, concretely. "The client followed up twice, and I had to apologize."
- The request: what you expect next time, precisely. "If a quote might be late, give me a heads-up the day before, and I'll warn the client."
What goes away: judgments ("you're careless"), generalizations ("always," "never"), and guesses about intentions ("you don't care").
When and how
- Quickly: within two days. A week later, nobody remembers the details, and the feedback feels like a file you've been building.
- In private: one on one, in person or on a call. Never in the team chat, never in front of a client.
- Out loud first for sensitive feedback. Writing comes afterward, to keep the request in one line.
- One topic at a time. Three criticisms at once, and the person remembers none of them.
- End with a question: "What would help you?" Sometimes the delay came from information that was missing.
10 examples, before and after
- Web agency Before: "Your page is full of bugs." After: "On the Contact page, the form doesn't send anything on mobile. The client spotted it before we did. Next time, test on a phone before telling me it's ready."
- Web agency Before: "You never answer clients." After: "Ms. Durand's message from Monday went unanswered until Thursday. She called Leah, frustrated. Can you reply the same day, even with 'Got it, I'll get back to you tomorrow'?"
- Contractor Before: "The job site was a mess." After: "Last night, the debris was still in the client's entryway. He told me this morning. Before we leave, we clear the entryway and sweep, every time."
- Contractor Before: "Be more careful with the tools." After: "The drill came back without its battery on Friday. On Monday, we lost an hour looking for it. At the end of the day, we check the toolbox against the list."
- Photographer Before: "Your culling isn't good." After: "In the Petit wedding selection, there were still about twenty blurry photos. I had to redo the cull. Before you send it to me, go through the reception photos once in full screen."
- Coach Before: "The scheduling is a mess." After: "Two clients were booked in the same slot on Tuesday. One left without a session. Check the calendar before confirming an appointment by text."
- Retail store Before: "The window display isn't great." After: "Since Saturday, the tags in the window don't match the products anymore. Two customers pointed it out. Monday mornings, check that every product has the right tag."
- Nonprofit Before: "You're not committed enough." After: "You signed up to staff the booth on Saturday and didn't show, without telling anyone. We were two people instead of three. If you can't make it, let me know the day before: I'll find someone."
- Meeting Before: "You talk over everyone." After: "In Monday's meeting, you interrupted Ines twice while she was presenting. She didn't get to finish. Next time, write your question down and ask it when she's done."
- Writing Before: "Your messages are impossible to follow." After: "Your message yesterday was twenty lines long, and the question was at the very end. I almost missed it. Put your request on the first line."
Positive feedback, just as precise
"Great job!" feels nice for a minute and teaches nothing. Positive feedback follows the same three parts, and it says what to do again.
- Vague: "Thanks for the presentation, it was great."
- Precise: "Your presentation to the client on Thursday opened with their problem, not with our services. They signed the next day and quoted your first slide. Keep that opening for the next ones."
Give at least as much of this as corrective feedback. A team that only hears criticism eventually stops listening.
The template to copy
FEEDBACK FOR [name]
The facts: [date] + [what happened, no judgment]
The impact: [what it caused, concretely]
The request: [what I expect next time]
My question: "What would help you?"
When: within 2 days. Where: in private.
Your turn
Think of feedback you've been putting off for days. Write it with the template: facts, impact, request. Reread it looking for "always," "never" and any judgments, and remove them. Then write a precise piece of positive feedback too, and give both this week, in private.
Recommended tool
All your projects in one place
Flopilot brings your tasks, documents, notes and conversations together by project, solo or as a team.
Premium
Unlock every course of the group Flopilot
Every lesson, new courses as soon as they come out, and the community. No commitment.