Skip to content
Floskool

Chapter 1 · Ready Replies

Replying to a negative review with Claude

Free lesson 10 minGroup Flopia

Follow this course in your space: your progress is saved, and the community answers your questions.

Follow for free

A one-star review, one evening, and you want to reply right away, in the heat of the moment. That's the worst time. Your reply isn't really for the person who wrote the review: it's for the dozens of people who'll read it before deciding where to go. Claude can help you write a calm, fair reply, as long as you give it the facts, and keep the decision for yourself.

Before you write: 3 questions

  1. What really happened? Find the order, the appointment, the date. Write down the facts, not how you feel.
  2. What's true in the review? There's almost always something true (a delay, a wait, a misunderstanding). That's the part you acknowledge.
  3. What can you offer? An exchange, a call back, an explanation, or nothing more than a sincere apology. Decide that yourself, before you open Claude.

And wait a few hours if you're angry. A reply the next morning beats a reply at midnight.

The complete prompt

Open Claude (claude.ai) and paste this text. Don't include the customer's full name: their first name or "the customer" is enough.

Help me reply publicly to a negative review.
I'm a [trade] in [city]. Here's the review (without the author's name):
"[paste the review]"

The facts on my side:
- [what happened, with dates, without judgment]
- [what's true in the review]
- [what's inaccurate, if anything]
What I'm offering: [gesture, call back, or nothing more than an apology].

Write 2 versions of the reply, each 4 to 6 lines long:
1. Thank them for the feedback, without a canned phrase.
2. Acknowledge exactly what's true, and apologize for that.
3. Calmly correct what's inaccurate, without blaming the customer.
4. Say what you've changed or what you're offering.
5. End with a way to contact you directly.

Off limits: contradicting how the customer felt, "we're sorry you
feel that way," "as stated in our terms," mentioning personal
information, promising anything I haven't listed.
Write like a person, not like a customer service department.

Read it over before you post

Take the version that sounds most like you, then check:

  • Every fact is accurate (date, service, what was said).
  • No personal information about the customer (full name, address, health details).
  • No promise you won't keep.
  • The tone is the one you'd use face to face, at the counter.
  • A reader who doesn't know the story can tell you take the problem seriously.

An example

The review: "Order arrived on the 26th when it was meant for Christmas. No word beforehand. Disappointed."

A good reply:

Thank you for taking the time to write, Claire. You're right
about one thing: your order shipped two days late
and we didn't let you know. That's our mistake, and we're sorry.
Since then, we send a message as soon as an order is delayed.
Write to us at [address]: we'd like to make it up to you.

It acknowledges what's true (the delay, the silence), says what's changed, and opens a door. It doesn't argue with how she felt.

Reviews you shouldn't handle alone

  • A review with insults, discriminatory language or personal information: report it to the platform with its reporting tool, rather than replying.
  • A review that looks fake (no customer by that name, no order): reply simply that you can't find their visit and invite them to contact you, then report it if that's confirmed.
  • A dispute that's taking a legal turn: don't reply publicly without advice.

Your turn

Take your latest average or negative review, even an old one. Go through the three questions, run the prompt, and compare the suggested reply with the one you posted (or didn't). Keep the best structure as a template.