Chapter 1 · The checklist
The chatbot doesn't decide on its own
Follow this course in your space: your progress is saved, and the community answers your questions.
Follow for freeA chatbot answers. It doesn't rule. In its advice on chatbots, France's CNIL points out that a conversation with a chatbot, without human involvement, cannot on its own be the basis for an important decision about the person. It's also plain business sense: a refusal delivered by a machine, with no recourse, is a lost customer and sometimes a bad review.
This lesson helps you spot the decisions that matter, take them away from the chatbot, and set up confirmation before any action.
What counts as an "important decision"
An important decision is one that changes something for the person: what they get, what they pay, what they're denied. Examples, business by business:
| Business | Decisions to keep for a human |
|---|---|
| Vacation rental | Turning down a booking, accepting a pet, refunding a cancellation |
| Plumber | Deciding a job isn't urgent, turning down a project |
| Coach, yoga teacher | Turning down a sign-up, judging that someone isn't at the right level or fitness |
| Lawyer | Saying whether a case is "worth it," taking on or turning down a client |
| Auto shop | Denying a warranty claim, approving a quote |
| Online store | Refusing a return, granting a refund or a goodwill gesture |
| Training provider | Accepting or rejecting an application |
The chatbot can inform on these topics ("pets are welcome with prior approval"), collect the request, and pass it along. It doesn't decide.
The instruction to copy
DECISIONS
You make NO decision that commits [business name] or changes the
visitor's situation: accepting, refusing, refunding, canceling,
granting a discount, judging whether a request is acceptable or not.
In these cases, you explain the rule if it's written in your
information, you collect the request, and you say:
"That's not my call, it's [first name]'s. I'm passing your request
along and they'll get back to you [time frame]."
You never hint that the answer will be yes or no.
The last line matters. "I'm passing it along, but it should be fine" is already a decision in the customer's mind.
Confirmation before any action
Some chatbots don't just talk: they can book a slot, send an email, log a request, or even change a page on your website. Simple rule: no action without explicit confirmation, and the person sees what's going to happen first.
On the customer's side
The chatbot sums up, then asks for a clear "yes."
Here's your request: cut and color appointment, Saturday morning if possible, under the name Leah, call back at 555 [...]. Shall I send it to the salon? (Yes / Let me fix something)
No booking saved on an ambiguous "ok" in the middle of a sentence. No action triggered because the customer answered a different question.
On your side
If your tool can change your website or your information (hours, text, services), it must show you the before and after and wait for your approval. A change to your hours applied without you reviewing it is a mistake shown to every visitor.
A human handoff that actually works
Taking decisions away from the chatbot is pointless if the handoff goes nowhere. Frustrating chatbots tend to share the same flaws: no way out to a human, an "I didn't understand" loop, a handoff to nobody in the evening, and a customer forced to repeat everything.
- The request passed along includes the whole conversation, so the customer has nothing to repeat
- The chatbot announces a response time you actually keep ("same business day," "within 24 hours")
- In the evening and on weekends, it says the reply will come the next business day
- After two misunderstandings, it offers the handoff instead of asking again
- You get a notification you actually see (email you read, phone)
- A backup person is planned for your vacations
Example: the vacation rental
A guest writes on a Sunday evening: "We're canceling because of a death in the family, will you refund us?" Bad answer: "Under our policy, no refund is possible within 30 days of arrival." Good answer: "I'm so sorry for your loss. I can't decide on a refund myself: I'm passing your message to Anne and Paul, who will reply by email tomorrow during the day."
The cancellation policy may well exist, but applying it to a human situation is a decision that belongs to the owners.
Your turn
- Fill in the decisions table for your business: at least three rows.
- Paste the "DECISIONS" instruction into your chatbot's instructions.
- Check whether your tool can trigger actions. If so, test the confirmation: it should sum up and wait for a clear "yes."
- Go through the handoff checklist, and fix what's missing before the end of the week.
Recommended tool
Flopia, the AI assistant from Flopix
Flopia is in testing. Join the waitlist to hear as soon as it opens.
Premium
Unlock every course of the group Flopia
Every lesson, new courses as soon as they come out, and the community. No commitment.